“Romantasy.”
Even typing the word makes me twitch a little. It sounds like something invented by a marketing department that ran out of coffee and started mashing syllables together for sport. And yet here we are. “Romantasy” has been dominating sales charts, bestseller lists, social feeds and book boxes for the last few years.
But here’s the question I keep circling back to: Is romantasy about to die? Or is it simply doing what every overgrown genre eventually does—splitting, mutating, and settling into something more stable? I suspect the latter.
When a Genre Gets Too Big for Its Boots
Every time a genre explodes, we see the same pattern.
- First: the label catches fire.
- Then: everyone piles in.
- Then: readers start demanding nuance.
We saw it with paranormal romance. We saw it with dystopian. We saw it with historicals when they ruled the shelves and then quietly retreated into their loyal, comfortable readership.
“Romantasy” has reached the awkward teenage phase. It’s too big to remain a single bucket. Readers no longer just want:
- Magic
- Romance
- Brooding immortal hero
- Heroine discovering mysterious powers
Now they want flavour.
They want political fantasy romance. Cozy fantasy romance. Dark fantasy romance. High spice, low spice, morally gray, found family, second-chance, queer epic court intrigue with dragons who have opinions.
The umbrella is straining. Which is why I suspect the term “romantasy” will fade—not because the stories disappear, but because the label fractures.
And honestly? Good. Because “Fantasy Romance” has been sitting there the whole time, perfectly respectable, perfectly clear, and not sounding like a glitter pen exploded on a marketing spreadsheet.
Is Romantasy the New Historicals?
Here’s the interesting comparison. There was a time when historical romance was the dominant force in romance publishing. Entire careers were built on dukes and ballrooms. Then contemporary surged. Paranormal swept in. Romantic suspense carved its territory.
Did historical die? No. It settled. It found its loyal readers and stopped trying to be everything to everyone.
I suspect fantasy romance will do the same. The froth will settle. The massive, viral hype cycles will cool. What remains will be authors who actually love fantasy worlds and romance arcs—not just the sales momentum. And those books will last.
The Fracturing Has Already Begun
You can see it happening now. We’re no longer talking about “romantasy” in one breath. We’re talking about:
- Romantasy with horror edges
- Cozy cottagecore fantasy romance
- Political epic fantasy with romantic subplot
- Monster romance in high fantasy settings
- Sci-fantasy romance hybrids
The niche within the niche within the niche. That’s not a dying genre. That’s a genre maturing.
But… Barbie?
Yes, apparently even Barbie has wandered into the fantasy romance arena. There is a book coming out in July: Barbie: Dreamscape. And honestly? That tells us something important. When a genre becomes broad enough that it can absorb something as culturally bright and plastic as Barbie and still function, it’s no longer fragile. It’s mainstream.
Which means it’s about to splinter. Because mainstream genres cannot stay monolithic for long. They either flatten into cliché… or they subdivide into specificity. Readers, bless them, prefer specificity.
What’s Next? Let’s Get Weird
If romantasy is fracturing, then let’s help it along. What’s the strangest mashup that might actually work?
Fantasy + professional wrestling.
Imagine rival magical houses settling disputes in enchanted arenas. Dramatic betrayals. Masks. Secret identities. Body slams with elemental magic.
Fantasy + deep sea diving.
Sunken kingdoms. Mermaid politics. Archaeologists who fall in love while decoding ancient ocean spells.
Fantasy + culinary competition.
Spell-infused cooking battles. Romance between rival chefs wielding enchanted knives.
Fantasy + corporate law.
Dragon hoards tied up in litigation. Sorcerers arguing contract loopholes.
Fantasy + space salvage.
Oops. That’s just me wandering back toward science fantasy.
But here’s the point: When a genre grows large enough, it invites experimentation. And experimentation is a sign of health, not decline.
So Will “Romantasy” Disappear?
The word might. (Please!) The stories won’t. I suspect five years from now we’ll look back and say, “Remember when everything was romantasy?”
And we’ll be browsing shelves labeled:
Fantasy Romance – Dark
Fantasy Romance – Cozy
Fantasy Romance – Epic
Fantasy Romance – Monster
Fantasy Romance – Historical
And it will feel calmer. More precise. Less glittery. And I, for one, will happily get behind “Fantasy Romance” as the umbrella term. It has history. It has dignity. It doesn’t sound like it was coined during a sugar rush.
Your Turn
What do you think? Is romantasy peaking? Is it splintering? Is it here to rule forever?
And more importantly: What fantasy romance mashup would you love to see?
Fantasy + pirates?
Fantasy + archaeology?
Fantasy + competitive chess?
Fantasy + professional wrestling?
Tell me. Let’s invent the next niche before the marketing department does.
Now available for preorder:
Camlann
Before, After, Always
Latest releases:
Kiss Across Time Box Three
The Grail and Glory
Breaking Point